Skip to content
Biblical History Atlas

Historical event dossier · Political, Religious

Hanani's report at Susa and Nehemiah's prayer (Chislev, Artaxerxes's 20th year)

Researched — not human reviewedRevision 1Last reviewed: not reviewed

No review items are open for this dossier. Classifications remain machine-proposed unless marked as approved by the owner.

Biblical references

Text: World English Bible (public domain). The ESV and NKJV are the preferred study translations and are referenced, not reproduced.

Nehemiah 1:1–11Narration
1 The words of Nehemiah the son of Hacaliah. Now in the month Chislev, in the twentieth year, as I was in Susa the palace, 2 Hanani, one of my brothers, came, he and certain men out of Judah; and I asked them about the Jews who had escaped, who were left of the captivity, and concerning Jerusalem. 3 They said to me, “The remnant who are left of the captivity there in the province are in great affliction and reproach. The wall of Jerusalem is also broken down, and its gates are burned with fire.” 4 When I heard these words, I sat down and wept, and mourned several days; and I fasted and prayed before the God of heaven, 5 and said, “I beg you, LORD, the God of heaven, the great and awesome God who keeps covenant and loving kindness with those who love him and keep his commandments, 6 let your ear now be attentive and your eyes open, that you may listen to the prayer of your servant which I pray before you at this time, day and night, for the children of Israel your servants, while I confess the sins of the children of Israel which we have sinned against you. Yes, I and my father’s house have sinned. 7 We have dealt very corruptly against you, and have not kept the commandments, nor the statutes, nor the ordinances, which you commanded your servant Moses. 8 “Remember, I beg you, the word that you commanded your servant Moses, saying, ‘If you trespass, I will scatter you among the peoples; 9 but if you return to me, and keep my commandments and do them, though your outcasts were in the uttermost part of the heavens, yet I will gather them from there, and will bring them to the place that I have chosen, to cause my name to dwell there.’ 10 “Now these are your servants and your people, whom you have redeemed by your great power and by your strong hand. 11 Lord, I beg you, let your ear be attentive now to the prayer of your servant, and to the prayer of your servants who delight to fear your name; and please prosper your servant today, and grant him mercy in the sight of this man.” Now I was cup bearer to the king.

Biblical account

Layer: Biblical text

In Chislev of the twentieth year, in Shushan the citadel, Hanani and men from Judah told Nehemiah that the survivors were in great trouble and Jerusalem's wall was broken down and its gates burned. Nehemiah wept, fasted and prayed, confessing Israel's sins and recalling the promise of gathering in Deut 30, and asked for favour before the king, whose cupbearer he was.

Historical overview

Layer: Historical reconstruction · Period: November–December 446 BC

On either explanation of 1:1 the report falls in Chislev of 446, about four months before the audience of Nisan 445 (Artaxerxes's twentieth year began 13 April 445 on Parker and Dubberstein's table). Susa was the winter residence of the Persian kings (Batten).[1, 2, 3]

Kingdoms: Achaemenid Persian Empire, Kingdom of Judah

Date and chronology derivation

Ranges are computed by the project's deterministic chronology engine from the biblical statements and each model's reign anchors. They are reconstructions, not independent dates.

447 BC – 445 BC

Model-independent (applies under every chronology model) · precision: regnal year

How this range was derived

Earliest bound

  1. “In the month Nisan, in the twentieth year of Artaxerxes the king” — Artaxerxes sends Nehemiah to rebuild Jerusalem, Nisan of his twentieth year (Neh 2:1–8) in regnal year reign of Artaxerxes I (Longimanus) (year 20) [reckoned accession, nisan new year] (Nehemiah 2:1)[1]Assumption: Nisan reckoning: year 20 began 1 Nisan = 13 Apr 445 (Parker & Dubberstein table). Neh 1:1 places Chislev "in the twentieth year" before Nisan of the twentieth year, which suggests an autumn (Tishri) year count; on that count the Nisan in question is spring 444. Not modelled here; recorded as a competing reconstruction.
  2. “in the month Chislev … in the month Nisan” — Artaxerxes sends Nehemiah to rebuild Jerusalem, Nisan of his twentieth year (Neh 2:1–8) months later Hanani's report at Susa and Nehemiah's prayer (Chislev, Artaxerxes's 20th year) (Nehemiah 1:1–2:1)Assumption: Chislev (IX) to Nisan (I) is about four months, whether the "twentieth year" of 1:1 is read on an autumn-based year (Keil) or emended to the nineteenth (Batten); both put the report in Chislev 446.

Latest bound

  1. “So the wall was finished in the twenty-fifth day of Elul, in fifty-two days” — The wall completed on 25 Elul after fifty-two days (Neh 6:15–19) in regnal year reign of Artaxerxes I (Longimanus) (year 20) [reckoned accession, nisan new year] (Nehemiah 6:15)[1, 2]Assumption: The year is not stated; the twentieth year of 2:1 is meant (Keil). On Parker & Dubberstein's table Elul of year 20 began 8 September 445, so 25 Elul = 2 October 445 and the 52 days began about 12 August (Keil: 3 Ab).
  2. “Nisan (2:1) … Elul (6:15)” — The wall completed on 25 Elul after fifty-two days (Neh 6:15–19) months later Artaxerxes sends Nehemiah to rebuild Jerusalem, Nisan of his twentieth year (Neh 2:1–8) (Nehemiah 6:15)Assumption: Nisan to 25 Elul of the same year is under six months.
  3. “in the month Chislev … in the month Nisan” — Artaxerxes sends Nehemiah to rebuild Jerusalem, Nisan of his twentieth year (Neh 2:1–8) months later Hanani's report at Susa and Nehemiah's prayer (Chislev, Artaxerxes's 20th year) (Nehemiah 1:1–2:1)Assumption: Chislev (IX) to Nisan (I) is about four months, whether the "twentieth year" of 1:1 is read on an autumn-based year (Keil) or emended to the nineteenth (Batten); both put the report in Chislev 446.

View on the timeline →

What else was happening? (model-independent)

  • Daniel's refusal of the king's food and the ten-day test (Dan 1:8–16): 606 BC – ?
  • Nebuchadnezzar's golden image on the plain of Dura (Dan 3:1–7): 603 BC – ?
  • Nebuchadnezzar's decree honouring the God of the three Judeans (Dan 3:28–30): 603 BC – ?
  • The refusal of Shadrach, Meshach and Abednego and the fiery furnace (Dan 3:8–27): 603 BC – ?
  • The thirty-day decree and Daniel in the lions' den (Dan 6:4–23): 539 BC – ?
  • Darius appoints 120 satraps and three chief officials (Dan 6:1–3, 28): 539 BC – ?
  • The accusers punished; Darius's decree honouring the God of Daniel (Dan 6:24–27): 539 BC – ?
  • Artaxerxes sends Nehemiah to rebuild Jerusalem, Nisan of his twentieth year (Neh 2:1–8): 446 BC – 444 BC
  • Artaxerxes I (Longimanus) (reign): 465 BC – 423 BC
  • Gedaliah governs from Mizpah and is assassinated (2 Kgs 25:22–26): 589 BC – ?
  • Accusations to Ahasuerus and the Rehum–Shimshai letter to Artaxerxes; the city's rebuilding stopped (Ezra 4:6–23): 537 BC – ?
  • Nehemiah arrives, inspects the walls by night and calls for rebuilding (Neh 2:9–20): 446 BC – 444 BC
  • The rebuilding of Jerusalem's wall and gates, section by section (Neh 3): 446 BC – 444 BC
  • Mockery, threats and the armed builders (Neh 4): 446 BC – 444 BC
  • The debt crisis and the remission of pledges (Neh 5:1–13): 446 BC – 423 BC
  • Plots against Nehemiah: Ono, the open letter, Shemaiah (Neh 6:1–14): 446 BC – 444 BC
  • The wall completed on 25 Elul after fifty-two days (Neh 6:15–19): 446 BC – 444 BC
  • Nehemiah's first governorship: twelve years, 20th–32nd year of Artaxerxes (445–433 BC): 446 BC – 444 BC
  • Jerusalem guarded under Hanani and Hananiah; the registry of the first returnees found (Neh 7:1–5): 446 BC – ?
  • Ezra reads the Law on the first day of the seventh month (Neh 7:73b–8:12): 446 BC – 444 BC
  • The Feast of Booths kept "as it is written" (Neh 8:13–18): 446 BC – 444 BC
  • The sealed covenant to keep the law and support the temple (Neh 9:38–10:39): 446 BC – 444 BC
  • The fast of the twenty-fourth day and the Levites' confession (Neh 9): 446 BC – 444 BC
  • Jerusalem repopulated: one in ten by lot (Neh 11): 446 BC – ?
  • The dedication of the wall of Jerusalem (Neh 12:27–13:3): 446 BC – 423 BC
  • The priestly and Levitical registers to the days of Jaddua (Neh 12:1–26): 446 BC – ?
  • The first "burden" of Zechariah 9–11 (undated oracle collection): 518 BC – ?
  • The second "burden" of Zechariah 12–14 (undated oracle collection): 518 BC – ?
  • Malachi's disputations with priests and people (Mal 1–4; undated, mid-fifth century BC): 465 BC – 423 BC
  • The institution of Purim; Mordecai second to the king (Esth 9:20–10:3): 474 BC – ?

Ancient and modern geography

Location confidence assumes the event as described. Whether it occurred is assessed in the claims below.

PlaceConnection to this eventLocation identification
Susa (Shushan)ShushWhere Nehemiah received the reportLocation confidence: certainSusa (Pleiades 912936): certain[4]
JerusalemJerusalem (Old City / City of David)The city reported onLocation confidence: certainPleiades representative point: certain[5]

View on the map →

Claims, evidence and classifications

Each claim is classified on its own. A classification describes the evidence for that specific claim, not for the event as a whole.

Hanani's report reached Nehemiah in Chislev 446 BC, about four months before the audience of Nisan 445.

Historically plausibleMachine-proposedHistorical reconstruction

Whether 1:1 uses an autumn-based year (Keil; Wellhausen via Batten) or should read "nineteenth year" (Batten), Chislev before Nisan 445 is Chislev 446. Ryle objects to the autumn-year explanation but the Julian result is the same. Depends on the identification of the king with Artaxerxes I.

Supporting

  • Year 20 began 13 April 445.[1]Strength: direct·Artaxerxes I table·Claim checked

Context

  • Autumn-based year: Chislev precedes Nisan in the same year.[2]Strength: indirect·pp. 163–164·Claim checked
  • "Twentieth year" an interpolation; it must be the nineteenth.[3]Strength: indirect·on 1:1·Claim checked

Research date 2026-10-13

Evidence by type

The same evidence regrouped by kind of source. Each item names the claims it bears on.

Archaeological evidence

None recorded for this event.

Scientific findings

None recorded for this event.

Ancient documents

None recorded for this event.

Modern news and announcements

None recorded for this event.

Reference works and summaries

Historical disputes and competing reconstructions

  • Nehemiah counts the year from autumn (Tishri)

    C. F. Keil (1873); J. Wellhausen (as reported by Batten)

    With a Tishri new year, Chislev (3rd month) precedes Nisan (7th) in the same twentieth year.[2, 3]

  • The "twentieth year" of 1:1 is an error for the nineteenth

    L. W. Batten (1913): an interpolation by the Chronicler

    Nisan of the twentieth year was the first month of that year, so Chislev before it was in the nineteenth.[3]

  • Objections to the autumn-year explanation

    H. E. Ryle (1893)

    Nehemiah dates by the Persian king and Babylonian month names; Nisan-based reckoning was almost universal; the Tishri new year is later (Seleucid era, per Jewish tradition).[6]

Related passages and events

FromRelationshipToBasis
this eventFollowed byhigh · Biblical textArtaxerxes sends Nehemiah to rebuild Jerusalem, Nisan of his twentieth year (Neh 2:1–8)Four months later Nehemiah petitioned the king.
this eventThematic parallelmedium · Historical reconstructionAccusations to Ahasuerus and the Rehum–Shimshai letter to Artaxerxes; the city's rebuilding stopped (Ezra 4:6–23)The broken walls and burned gates may reflect the halt imposed under Artaxerxes (Ezra 4:23) — Guzik; the identification of Ezra 4's kings is disputed.[7]
this eventThematic parallelmedium · Biblical textDaniel 9:4–19A confession of national sin in exile (cf. Daniel's prayer).

Prophetic relationships

No prophecy or proposed-fulfillment relationships have been recorded for this event.

Commentary references

Layer: Interpretation. This is commentary, not historical evidence.

Guzik connects the broken walls with the earlier failed attempt of Ezra 4:6–23.[7]

Unanswered questions and research gaps

    Research process

    2 logged searches
    DateQueryWhereUseful
    2026-10-13Keil, Ryle, Batten on Neh 1:1 (archive.org); P&Dlocal text4
    2026-10-13Enduring Word Nehemiah 1web fetch1

    Sources

    1. 1.
      Parker, Richard A., Dubberstein, Waldo H.. Babylonian Chronology 626 B.C.–A.D. 45 (SAOC 24). University of Chicago Press (Oriental Institute). archive.orgClaim checkedAcademic monographRead through the Internet Archive OCR text of the Oriental Institute PDF; OCR has digit errors (e.g. "589" for 539) checked against context. The 1956 revised edition was not consulted.Verification log
    2. 2.
      Keil, C. F., Taylor, Sophia (trans.). Biblical Commentary on the Books of Ezra, Nehemiah, and Esther (Clark's Foreign Theological Library). T. & T. Clark, Edinburgh, 1873. archive.orgClaim checkedScholarly commentaryRead through the Internet Archive OCR text.Verification log
    3. 3.
      Batten, Loring W.. A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Books of Ezra and Nehemiah (International Critical Commentary). T. & T. Clark / Scribner, 1913. archive.orgClaim checkedScholarly commentaryRead through the Internet Archive OCR text.Verification log
    4. 4.
      Pleiades contributors. Susa/Seleucia ad Eulaeum — Pleiades place 912936. Pleiades (pleiades.stoa.org). pleiades.stoa.orgClaim checkedInstitutional databaseRepresentative point read from the Pleiades JSON record: lon 48.253537054323495, lat 32.189934471571.Verification log
    5. 5.
      Pleiades contributors. Ierusalem/Hierosolyma — Pleiades place 687928. Pleiades (pleiades.stoa.org). pleiades.stoa.orgClaim checkedInstitutional databaseRepresentative point read from the Pleiades JSON record: lon 35.234978, lat 31.7771895.Verification log
    6. 6.
      Ryle, Herbert Edward. The Books of Ezra and Nehemiah, with Introduction, Notes and Maps (Cambridge Bible for Schools and Colleges). Cambridge University Press, 1893. archive.orgClaim checkedScholarly commentaryRead through the Internet Archive OCR text.Verification log
    7. 7.
      Guzik, David. Nehemiah 1 — Enduring Word Bible Commentary. Enduring Word. enduringword.comClaim checkedTheological commentaryInterpretive resource — not historical corroboration.Verification log